This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Which program is best for me?

Jump to new

Synergy

Joined
26 February 2007
Posts
358
Reactions
0
I'm curretly working on a trading system using Excel. It's becoming unproductive to continue with Excel becasue of the time it takes to make changes to the system and test them. So i'm looking for something else.

I know very little about the software available. But I want something that I can convert my current excel system too and backtest over a longer period (current only using 3 years). I have a feeling its going to be a difficult task.

Is the coding for these programs pretty limitless? and is it easy to pick up?

Also what are the costs involved and where does the data come from?

Cheers
 
The program you are after is MS Excel 2008, ok that didn't help Maybe post why excel is limiting you so that people could find you a workaround.
 
Personally I'd be looking at Amibroker. Probably cheaper than excel 2008 too If you're only looking at EOD then just get the std version, think it's about $US130 but check the website.

If you can code in excel then it shouldn't take you long to pick up the Amibroker AFL language. Lots of good resources around to help you out.

Lots of places to get free EOD data such as:
http://www.float.com.au
STI

Or most brokers should let you download EOD data.

Hope that helps.

Cheers
AV
 
if you are after flexible coding then I would say that Amibroker is the most cost effective solution
 
Value for money Amibroker is the best by far...........
 
Not to say i've ruled out Amibroker but I'd been considering the Metastock/tradesim combo rather than Amibroker, but the price has scared me off so far...

I've got a trial version of excel 2007 and i'm finding that better. At least i can fit my data into a single file! although its 300mb+ and very very slow to do anything at all.

I'm basically after a pretty limitless self coding program that can handle the job. Excel does what i want code-wise but is far too slow.

Can amibroker handle pretty much anything you throw at it? Does it slow down if you add more code or more data? Also I'm assuming it will have the basic statistics functions like avg, max, min, std dev that sort of thing?

Thanks for the help all.
 
Amibroker has everything you could possibly want. The code is VERY similar to Metastock, you can also quickly convert metstock code to ami code. It has all the standard indicators built in plus you program in whatever else you want or download from the net.

I have a fairly large database and she still rips along, never had any problem with the speed and my PC is several years old.

I believe you can also use ami with tradesim though I have never done it so can't really comment.

For the substantial price difference, I can't really see what MS offers that is so much better. Having said that, I haven't personally used MS so maybe someone who has used both can comment?

Cheers
AV
 
Synergy AB have a trial version give it a go, I have been long term MS user I think its a good programed except when you lose your favorites file AAAARRR (this alone drove me to AB) and now am using AB, AB far more flexible than MS and much cheaper,

I don't use the back testing function so cannot comment

Focus
 


Yes, AB does work with TradeSim although you do need some additional code to convert the AB results into a format which TradeSim understands.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Gold coins: Which are the best Australian individual coins to buy for Grandchildren?
Replies
16
Views
2K
Garpal Gumnut
Fun with ChatGPT
2
Replies
24
Views
4K
SirRumpole
Competency and trying to maintain standards
2
Replies
27
Views
4K
sptrawler
How valuable are two parent families?
2
Replies
28
Views
5K
Value Collector
System optimisation: IS training vs. OOS testing, and Paper Trading
Replies
10
Views
3K
Garpal Gumnut
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...