Nothing gobsmacking, just curious whether anyone has a good understanding of why the range dropped so markedly at the end of 2011?
How about using a long term chart of the XJO and an ATR?
There is a problem with range as a way to measure volatility for an intraday fader.
Rarely do you actually trade the daily range. If you have days when it just opens and grinds in 1 direction very slowly all day it is very hard to trade.
My point was in reference to why there is no more prop traders and locals on the SPI. Just small retail fighting it out with the arb bots. Prop traders are active, 20 trades a day at least. No way in the world you'll find that on the SPI.
Yeah fair enough I guess, but dunno why the prop traders have to trade all day every day, instead of trading market regime appropriate setups?
I mean, if one of those setups I mentioned above was triggered I would be in and watching/waiting for the close, rather than looking for an exit to enter the next trade, market is telling me something on those days.
Funny isn't it. Retail wants a few good setups, maybe even 1 per day. Prop wants 100.
There is a problem with range as a way to measure volatility for an intraday trader.
Rarely do you actually trade the daily range. If you have days when it just opens and grinds in 1 direction very slowly all day it is very hard to trade. If you fluff up a few trades in the morning going against the direction by the time you flip there is nothing left to get you back to even. Sooner or later you should start seeking out something that is trade-able.
Just for the record CanOz, when you are looking at a longer term chart of ATR, or StdDev or similar measures you should really normalise by a mean price or current close because 10pts ATR when the index is priced 100pts is different from a 10pts ATR when the index is prices 1000pts.
The most common normalised historical vol measure is probably 'bollinger bandwidth'. This only takes into account closing prices, you can do the same with ATR.
View attachment 46762
The pane 3 is BollingerBandwidth(20,1) -- that is, 1 stddev normalised by the 20 period mean.
The pane 2 pane is ATR(14)/Close -- that is 14 day average of True Range normalised by the current close
The pane 1 that is my own personal code so I won't disclose it, but you can see it's not that different anyway. Less smoothing basically.
However, since XJO is not a really representative due to staggered opening times etc I've included BHP to show a better example of intraday vol.
View attachment 46763
In this case pane 1 is bandwidth, pane 2 is prop sinner, pane 3 is normalised ATR.
Thanks for the clarification Sinner. You are much more technical than I, and more so its seems since i was last on here frequently. To what do you owe your knowledge?
Cheers,
CanOz
Interesting Sinner, are a fully systematic trader yet?
What markets do you now trade? DO you trade the SPI?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?