This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Should shorting be suspended/banned?

Should 'shorting' be banned?

  • Suspended

    Votes: 24 10.3%
  • Banned

    Votes: 69 29.7%
  • No

    Votes: 139 59.9%

  • Total voters
    232
Right...

So because you can't answer a legitimate question because of an ideology, you deflect answering said question by claiming to be a stirrer.

I don't buy it.
 
And I'm not selling it. Even if I was you couldn't afford it.
Lol.

Maybe if you increased the margin (like they tried to do with oil) to about a gazillion dollars.

The reason you wont answer the question is because you can't. Pretty simple really.
 
Lol.

Maybe if you increased the margin (like they tried to do with oil) to about a gazillion dollars.

The reason you wont answer the question is because you can't. Pretty simple really.

This has gone on so long and with my old age dementia I can't even remember the Question. By now you don't deserve an answer anyway.

End of story.
 
This has gone on so long and with my old age dementia I can't even remember the Question. By now you don't deserve an answer anyway.

End of story.

Still Nioka good to see there is still life in the Old Dog
 
Noika, I have a good news story for your tomentors.

In the Brisbane paper today they had a list of the 10 top Queenslanders in the 2008 BRW Young Rich List. And guess what;

Four of them were hedge fund traders.
 
Noika, I have a good news story for your tomentors.

In the Brisbane paper today they had a list of the 10 top Queenslanders in the 2008 BRW Young Rich List. And guess what;

Four of them were hedge fund traders.

wasnt one also a motor-cross rider !?
join krusty demons, break my body for $1mil per show, sure as hell alot better than the current market predicaments!
 
What about the guy who brought a coal mine for $30mil and then sold it to MCC for $275mil. Not a bad trade.
 
Noika, I have a good news story for your tomentors.

In the Brisbane paper today they had a list of the 10 top Queenslanders in the 2008 BRW Young Rich List. And guess what;

Four of them were hedge fund traders.

Yeah and they are long micro-cap Asian funds!!!!!!!!

Facts, my friends, help bust a lot of confusion.
 
The Crusty boys definately deserve every penny they get.

They are crazy mofos!
 
Noika, I have a good news story for your tomentors.

I thought I had done with this thread but I have to comment here. Don't label them tomentors, I don't consider that I have been tormented, I wouldn't allow that to happen. never have, never will. Verbally challenged, but over 70 odd years ago I was told that "sticks and stones may break your bones but words can never hurt you."
If someone insults you the best way to infuriate them is to agree with them.

That's enough rot, back to profitable investing.
 
That's enough rot, back to profitable investing.

Just because you call it "investing" doesn't change the fact that you are a trader. All you do is a form of pairs trading - just because you use F/A instead of T/A does not make it investing.

Even the tax dept class you as a trader.

You're quite happy to run around this forum boasting about how much money you made last FY but the thing is you've made it by trading stocks - how is this any different to any of the traders you dispise for not being legitimate investors?
You profit from the swings and roundabouts of the market, again no different from any other trader in the world.
Now you want to kick up a stink about "unethical" traders & hedge funds manipulating the market by shorting but were quite happy to profit from it while prices were going up - a bit hypocritical don't you think?

You've also jumped on your high horse in this debate but when asked questions about your stance and how this might affect other aspects of the market you obviously have no understanding of you deflect the questions and refuse to answer instead of just admiting you've got in over your head and you don't understand how that part of the market works. And then wonder why people take you to task.

<end of rant>
 
Looks like the Church of England has something to say.

 

WOW!!!

Glad to see though that I have the same attitude to the matter as the Archbishop of York.

And now I see the German finance minister has joined in to support my point.
 
Sept. 26 (Bloomberg) -- China's cabinet agreed to let investors buy shares on credit and sell borrowed stock to help develop Asia's second-largest market after prices and trading volumes slumped, an official familiar with the plan said. The State Council signed off on a China Securities Regulatory Commission plan submitted this month to allow margin lending and short selling, said the official, who declined to be identified as he isn't authorized to speak on the issue.


blessem
 
This has gone on so long and with my old age dementia I can't even remember the Question. By now you don't deserve an answer anyway.

End of story.

Wow.

And you really proved your point there.

Others have asked you a legitimate question and it deserves to be answered.

Should shorting be banned from oil?
 
WOW!!!

Glad to see though that I have the same attitude to the matter as the Archbishop of York.
Not many who know how markets work do though:

http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/alex_s...rchbishops_are_wrong_shortselling_is_virtuous

 
I'd say the clergy are incredibly economically literate Wayne...

After all, for centuries they stole and controlled the wealth of the unquestioning, uneducated and illiterate masses. It's a pity none of them could short the church. They might have had to live up to their actual words and teachings then.
 

LOL good point.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...