Great strategy
@divs4ever, I do a similar thing in my investing forum. Its hard to tell how good management are, but once you spot rotten eggs its imperative to avoid wherever they go!
I try to avoid narrative in reports & presentations, it's too easy to be seduced into buying the story instead of the business. My focus is on the financial reports and understanding how the business works, capital allocation, strength of balance sheet, ROIIC, FCF, unit economics/margins etc.
I also have developed a process to look thru a business at a fairly high level that allows me to decide within a few minutes whether a business is worthy of a deeper dive. This not only saves time but also allows me to look at more businesses overall.
I suspect the most important thing is to develop a process that you are happy with and suits your personality, this helps you develop conviction in positions and makes it easier to weather the inevitable ups and downs of the market.