- Joined
- 14 February 2005
- Posts
- 15,851
- Reactions
- 19,179
In order, the steps we take as the grid operator in these events are:
- Turn off large-scale solar and wind farms.
- Turn off large-scale solar systems such as shopping centres and factories.
- Turn off the exporting of rooftop solar using the regulated Relevant Agent and Dynamic Export functions.
- Turn off any remaining exporting rooftop solar using our Emergency Voltage Management (EVM) function.
It is only a matter of time before old style inverters have to be replaced, they will just make it like smoke detectors and Earth leakage cct breakers, while the requirement is to put more in, they don't advertise bad news.For those who want the details:
Step 4 is relevant to all older solar systems, which are still the majority of residential installations, and is quite literally just pushing up the distribution voltage so as to shed enough rooftop solar generation which will trip or at least curtail output.
The real problem is that most people think it is all fine, but when you think that I'm putting is a brand new 5kW system, that is throttled to 3kW when in reality we need as much as possible and somehow this is magically going to be sorted in 6 years, yeh right.What you don't want is the situation that actually exists in SA.
It was left too late and the workaround is simply to crank up the distribution voltage until sufficient solar generation trips off.
Needless to say, intentionally sending overvoltage into every home and small business isn't ideal and brings about "the law of unintended consequences" one of which is reports that as well as shutting down solar, it also shuts down at least some EV chargers. That's not a good outcome obviously, cutting load is the opposite of what's required.
Remotely curtailing inverters via commanding them to do so is theoretically a far nicer way but not without problems as well with the implementation. It's all well and good until someone who's lost grid supply completely, and has an inverter with battery operating in backup mode as an islanded power system, has it remotely shut down. Since the loss of power means the house also loses internet, there's no way to send it a command to restart it.
Consumers who've got $10k+ systems providing backup power, and who've had that system disabled during an actual power failure, tend to get extremely angry....
That is some volatility!Battery operation in Victoria over the past 24 hours.
They're mostly operating in one direction at any given time, either charge or discharge, but there's a lot of volatility there, their output or load is rapidly fluctuating.
Above the zero line is generation into the grid, below the line is charging from it.
View attachment 168768
A good question that I haven't seen an detailed information about.I wonder if there has been any research done on how this sort of volatility affects battery life over the medium to long term.
Is there possibly a different pricing structure depending on whether its a stepped usage versus FCAS? Maybe the Horsdale suppliers are happy taking a higher price for more erratic usage?One thing that is clear is that different operators are adopting very different approaches. Eg AGL have very clear "preferred" levels of output for the Torrens Island battery with a chart over time looking like a series of steps up and down, they're trying to operate close to those preferred points where possible (noting it's not always possible but most of the time it is). In contrast Neoen aren't doing that with the Hornsdale battery, they're far happier with erratic operation providing FCAS.
Might be few businesses putting in big solar panels soon after 4 days of no power41degrees C, the last thing you need is an extended power outage, been there done that.
Spare a thought for those in Kalgoorlie, Kambalda 60km away has its own backup power, the daughter in law is there working ATM, says it is mayhem 30,000 people from Kalgoorlie trying to fit in the shop and petrol station.
Welcome to a World without power, for some it will be the first taste, Kal has been pretty good since the 220kv line and the gas pipeline have been installed.
No power, no fuel, no alcohol as DFES warns regional WA blackouts could last up to a week
The Department of Fire and Emergency services has warned residents across the Goldfields and Wheatbelt to prepare for ongoing blackouts over the next seven days.www.abc.net.au
Thousands of residents who have spent the day sweltering in 41C temperatures now have no access to fuel, following a huge power outage across Western Australia's Goldfields and Wheatbelt.
This afternoon, Main Roads said there was no fuel available in Kalgoorlie or Coolgardie because of the power outage.
Meanwhile, queues for fuel at Kambalda, 60 kilometres south of Kalgoorlie, are huge.
Western Power's executive manager of asset operations Zane Christmas said the Kalgoorlie outage was caused yesterday when lightning struck a critical communications tower near Merredin and a network that fed the Goldfields town tripped.
He said Synergy then started generators which restored power to about 7,000 of the 23,000 customers cut off last night.
But some of the generators had now suffered technical challenges, he said.
"So we are relying on Synergy technicians to address those as quickly as we can."
Mr Christmas said he did not know when power would be restored.
Ralph English said he had never experienced such a long outage during his 68 years in Mukinbudin in the eastern Wheatbelt.
"All day Sunday we had no power, [it was] on and off for the most of Monday and then Tuesday about 1:30 it went off," he said.
"And it's been off ever since."
Mr English drove about 40 kilometres to get phone service and said his local petrol station and supermarket could not open due to the internet being down.
He said he was worried about elderly residents and people who could not drive to leave the region, given yesterday's 46C heat.
"I don't really know how they're coping. It's been so hot."
So true, it has been a long time, since an outage like this.Might be few businesses putting in big solar panels soon after 4 days of no power
Love that confidence there....You couldn't rely on the diesel power station always running through the night, but you had to be at work on time.
Yep I've had some weird $hit happen in my time, I remember once we had finished work for the day in very touristy town in the NW of WA.Love that confidence there....
This is a problem in itself.Mr English drove about 40 kilometres to get phone service and said his local petrol station and supermarket could not open due to the internet being down.
My guess a lightning strike, but it shows how fragile it is, there is a 220kv line and a gas line, plus diesel backup on the GT's.This is a problem in itself.
The idea that the internet is required in order for someone to buy something that's sitting on a shelf right in front of them is really quite ridiculous.
As for Kalgoorlie well there's 5 gas turbines total 160MW there to my understanding, 2 at West Kalgoorlie (50MWl) and 3 at Parkeston power station (110MW) , as well as the 220kV line to the SWIS and also 132kV transmission south to Kambalda with its 42MW generating capacity. Must be quite a bit of damage if they can't get anything at all running in or into Kalgoorlie.
There's another 42MW gas turbine at the nickel smelter too that I failed to mention previously.Haven't heard anything about Parkeston PS (total capacity 110MW) though and what's stopping that being used to put the lights on. Physically it's on the outskirts of Kalgoorlie and has three open cycle gas turbines. Even if it can't meet all load, limited supply is better than no supply if they could get that running.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?