- Joined
- 5 April 2008
- Posts
- 162
- Reactions
- 0
Did anyone else watch the SBS program on Fish and Japan last night? They had an interesting segment on KIKI university and NBT breeding. One point that stuck into my mind is that it takes 10kg of Macrel to grow 1kg of tuna. Lower FCR than i thought.
Yes, I watched this program Basilica.
The growth rates ( timeframe ) and FCR is the main concern I have with SBT.
To give you some examples of FCR :
1. Tassal Salmon - 1.5 / 1.0
2. Chicken - 2.5 / 1.0 ( Note : Chicken feed is low cost )
3. YTK ( Cleanseas ) - 4.0 / 1.0
4. SBT - 10 / 1.0 ( wild mackeral )
You can see from this table that Cleanseas has been unable to improve the FCR for YTK and this is, partly, why they are struggling with profitibilty.
I have concerns that they will not be able to acheive an acceptable FCR for SBT which will need around 3 years growout time.
The 10 / 1.0 is for wild caught mackeral and would be commercially unviable for CSS if this was to be their FCR for SBT, however, they will be relying on Ridley SBT feedmix to lower this FCR. It will need to be a substantial improvement on the Kinki FCR highlighted in the program.
I thought CSS had developed (with the help of some other Aussie company) a new type of feed that is cheap to manufacture? This means that the cost of food for the SBT is significantly lower than mackeral making this a moot proposition.
Please correct me if I am wrong.
Hi Oracle, One factor i should have stated is the difference between dry and wet feed when comparing FCR. The Mackeral is wet and contains a lot of water weight that does not contribute to SBT weight. In your list
1 Tassal 1.5:1 is dry weight
2 Chicken 2.5:1 ??? not sure
3 YTK 4:1 ??? dry weiight i think
4 SBT (mackeral) 10:1 Wet weight
Do you know if 2 and 3 are wet or dry?
A credit to CSS and ridley is the work in developing products to lower final feed cost.
Basilica,
Chicken feed is small dry pellets. CSS's YTK feed is dry feed distributed by their recently launched feeding barge " Ulysses " .
I think they will need to get their FCR down to at least 2.5 : 1 for both YTK and SBT in order to maintain cost control during the growout period.
Volume is much higher today compared to recent days. Perhaps some details of the expected announcement is leaking a little. The move seems to be down.
Interesting. Their half year report should be coming out very soon, perhaps that is it?
Heh, or perhaps it is the fact that they said the report would be out in mid Feb but it isnt out yet and people are getting skittish
udging by last announcements their Interim should be between the 23rd-26th Feb, but I can't see any definite time listed. Not sure what positive results it could bring except to say they are debt free and progressing favourably with the spawning.
They have another spawning update in March, so they say.
If they could spend as much time in promoting themselves through the print and media instead of hiding behind a flashy website the stock price might acutally go up.
It's like they don't have confidence in their own ability and it is showing through.
Support has been broken and it slowly sliding away. Something needs to be done.
In March, it wont be a "spawning update", it will be a "we have SBT in cages at sea" update. At the moment, the fish are spawning and eating rotifers.
Anyway, they said that they are keeping quiet because they have industry secrets to lose. Its a bit strange at the moment - this phase is going to make or break the company but they cant tell us about it...grrr!
Heh, at 23c they are super cheap considering they were above 30c and no new news has come out since!
Interesting. Their half year report should be coming out very soon, perhaps that is it?
Heh, or perhaps it is the fact that they said the report would be out in mid Feb but it isnt out yet and people are getting skittish
In March, it wont be a "spawning update", it will be a "we have SBT in cages at sea" update. At the moment, the fish are spawning and eating rotifers.
Anyway, they said that they are keeping quiet because they have industry secrets to lose. Its a bit strange at the moment - this phase is going to make or break the company but they cant tell us about it...grrr!
Heh, at 23c they are super cheap considering they were above 30c and no new news has come out since!
I am biting my nails while waiting for the "they're in offshore cages" announcement.
I am concerned, make that deeply concerned. I've bought in on several occasions. The highest price I paid was 58c and not long after that I think the SP was almost 80c. My break even point is much lower and the longer this goes the higher the gains that are required just to break even.
I'll hold for the simple reason that I now have much less to lose! Even if they hit 10c I won't be buiyng more.
CSS need to get some good results and they need them quick. The economy is becoming shakier by the day and if they're planning on another capital raising in the futre then they won't get any interest if this current trend continues. Banks won't go near CSS. I thought the last SPP price of 25c was way too low but in hindsight, it was high and everyone that took part has now lost narly 10%
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?