Dona Ferentes
Did the Thessalonians write back?
- Joined
- 11 January 2016
- Posts
- 20,135
- Reactions
- 27,787
yes indeed, belli, I have never sold any. Board and Management have continued soothing words , backed up by consistent performance.Thanks @Dona Ferentes. Additional income to hit the bank given I hold a greater number of shares than I did this time last year.
let's hope the NTA discount is cyclical. At today's AGM, they put the casewith ARG now ex-dividend of 18c and trading around $8.80, the company has started reporting a weekly NTA, most likely to try and reduce the discount
Just decided to help your SMSF @Dona Ferentes and put a buy order on both arg and ali.let's hope the NTA discount is cyclical. At today's AGM, they put the case
View attachment 186257
.
... and some commentary ... "In addition to focusing on dividends we are searching for relative value in the market. This is a challenge as most of the upward movement in the market is not supported by material earnings growth. This is further exacerbated by the continued ‘de-equitisation’ of the Australian share market. This dynamic undermines traditional valuation methods with increasing compulsory superannuation inflows inflating prices in a shrinking share market.
"The domestic banks' recent performance has been phenomenal, resulting in record valuations. A number of the banks will report their full-year results beginning next week and we expect continued strong earnings results with the potential for further capital management.
"One factor driving the bank’s outperformance has been the lack of investor interest in resources stocks due to a weak and uncertain China outlook. However, the recent stimulus announcements in China may see some shift into resources, which would likely be funded from the banks.
.
View attachment 186256
.
With no debt, cash available and a diversified portfolio, we believe Argo is well-positioned to navigate the evolving economic cycle, applying our conservative, long-term investment approach.
timely.Just decided to help your SMSF @Dona Ferentes and put a buy order on both arg and ali.
Some small move PM to other assets
yes sir. could you perhaps help me with a post-tax NTA for Berkshire Hathaway ?I would just point out that Argo is at a discount to its pre-tax NTA. Its actually trading at a slight premium to its after-tax NTA.....
Post tax NTA for Argo is probably around $8.62 and the share price is currently at $9. So currently trading at a premium to post tax NTA of around 4.5%
Agreed. It's a company, been around for 80 years.The post tax NTA is fairly irrelevant for a LIC.
They are not about to liquidate all their holdings and the value of their portfolio that earns them their dividends is best measured by the pre-tax NTA.
I understand what you are saying but its relevant in the sense that you could go out and replicate their portfolio (approximately) by buying the underlying shareholdings directly on the market and not have the legacy tax liability. So thereby by looking at the post tax NTA it gives you an idea how much you are paying (the premium to post tax NTA) for the stock picking expertise of the Argo investment team so in that way its a baseline for comparison. Besides in any given year they will sell some portion of their shares and pay some capital gains tax so the reality from the perspective you are talking about lies somewhere in between the pre-tax and the post tax NTA.The post tax NTA is fairly irrelevant for a LIC.
They are not about to liquidate all their holdings and the value of their portfolio that earns them their dividends is best measured by the pre-tax NTA.
You have misunderstood this. If you go out and replicate their portfolio by buying the share holdings you will pay the pre-tax NTA, not the post tax NTA.I understand what you are saying but its relevant in the sense that you could go out and replicate their portfolio (approximately) by buying the underlying shareholdings directly on the market and not have the legacy tax liability.
I believe this is what VH was saying so everyone agrees,You have misunderstood this. If you go out and replicate their portfolio by buying the share holdings you will pay the pre-tax NTA, not the post tax NTA.
If instead you buy shares in the LIC, when the LIC is trading for less than its pre-tax NTA you get the portfolio at a discount to what you would pay to buy the portfolio.
I did not misunderstand anything. You missed my point entirely. The if you spend the pre-tax NTA you could replicate the portfolio but you do not have the attached legacy capital gains tax liability hence its not an equal position.You have misunderstood this. If you go out and replicate their portfolio by buying the share holdings you will pay the pre-tax NTA, not the post tax NTA.
If instead you buy shares in the LIC, when the LIC is trading for less than its pre-tax NTA you get the portfolio at a discount to what you would pay to buy the portfolio.
bought back another 100k on Friday ... must have a fair idea what they're worth / capital management.I'm happy to agree to disagree on this one.
I fully understand what you are saying about the CGT liability, but many LICs are long term holders and may never realise that liability.
I prefer to use the pre-tax NTA when deciding if a LIC is a buying opportunity, but if you prefer the post-tax NTA, that's fine.
I just prefer to err on the side of conservatism and hence I use whichever figure is the lower figure. If post tax NTA is lower (the most common case) I use that and if pre-tax NTA is lower (some LICs have accumulated tax losses) then I use that.I prefer to use the pre-tax NTA when deciding if a LIC is a buying opportunity, but if you prefer the post-tax NTA, that's fine.
You did? Or management did,? That is a hefty positionbought back another 100k on Friday ... must have a fair idea what they're worth / capital management.
haha. ARG did. announced to ASXYou did? Or management did,? That is a hefty position
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?