Australian (ASX) Stock Market Forum

Joined
3 April 2011
Posts
127
Reactions
27
I'm specifically referring to trading platforms in Australia here.
I'm also not naming any providers as I'm willing to believe they could potentially improve if given the chance.

What I've found when looking through stock trading platforms provided by Australian Firms is that even for the more expensive monthly subscriptions you don't get near what you get from free platforms provided by say U.S based platforms. It's terrible.

I've gone through several now and I'm absolutely shocked that the one's I've reviewed don't even provide VWAP. The screeners are terrible, and their charts provide tones of useless indicators which nobody uses.

It's almost like those platforms are created to steer or fool you into buying stocks to support the institutional buyers/seller who also provide the software.

Yahoo Finance and TradingView are the two most comprehensive platforms I can find. It's amazing. Yahoo charts provide all the VWAP derived studies and a bunch of useful widgets.

I'm also amazed that I haven't seen or heard anyone discuss this in the past. So I'm wondering what others have found in relation to this? I haven't looked at IB yet but will do so.

So it's really difficult to find a subscription based platform which provides the basics like VWAP, Risk/Reward drawing tools, Comparrison overlays, and Volume Profile indicators all in the one chart.

How have others got around this? The market for this kind of thing in Australia is absolutely terrible. It's almost like these providers have gone to work to provide the bare minimum and have failed to achieve even that.
 
Joined
10 August 2008
Posts
2,136
Reactions
314
I'm specifically referring to trading platforms in Australia here.
I'm also not naming any providers as I'm willing to believe they could potentially improve if given the chance.

What I've found when looking through stock trading platforms provided by Australian Firms is that even for the more expensive monthly subscriptions you don't get near what you get from free platforms provided by say U.S based platforms. It's terrible.

Yeah totally agree,

I guess the fact of the matter is most Aussie firms are just banks with stockbroking arms using Commercial Off The Shelf junk passing it off as a trading platform, most people probably couldn't care less with a few buy and holds with the bank that gave them a home loan or term deposit.
 
Joined
3 April 2011
Posts
127
Reactions
27
Yeah totally agree,

I guess the fact of the matter is most Aussie firms are just banks with stockbroking arms using Commercial Off The Shelf junk passing it off as a trading platform, most people probably couldn't care less with a few buy and holds with the bank that gave them a home loan or term deposit.

I'm just amazed that I have to look offshore for better value. In an affluent country like Australia with an active day trading and investment community, I can't even find a decent trading platform.

Not one with the exception if Iguana Spark which I think you pay a hell if allot to use in my view.
 
Joined
10 August 2008
Posts
2,136
Reactions
314
I'm just amazed that I have to look offshore for better value. In an affluent country like Australia with an active day trading and investment community, I can't even find a decent trading platform.

Not one with the exception if Iguana Spark which I think you pay a hell if allot to use in my view.

Yep, but I think we are a nation of property investors, that's where the demand is, real estate and banking, many people still view derivatives with suspicion, that's why only discuss with very few people in my everyday life.

Personally I always wanted to keep most of my holdings in CHESS but still have access to a sophisticated platform and decent option brokerage rates, therefore I do my stuff across a couple of accounts, a big 4 bank is one, finally in the process of winding this one down but keeping trading capabilities for backup, had some issues with my local bank broker during the recent rout, it was pretty unsettling, I suspect some of their clients were too short unlimited risk gamma which had knock on effects down the line, suspicion only can't be sure.

No issues on the other hand with Interactive Brokers, apart from a decent platform and awesome brokerage rates the systems are designed with some pretty vigilant risk management methodology, big consideration to be aware of in the overall scheme of things, when things get hot you don't need the extra worries of rouge traders taking down the brokerage and causing pain for the rest of the clientele.
 
Last edited:
Top