Australian (ASX) Stock Market Forum

Queensland Border needs to remain closed to NSW

Joined
Jan 2, 2006
Posts
10,050
Reactions
1,774
It is understandable that Mrs Berejiklian the Premier of NSW wishes to loosen the hordes of grey nomads, bogans and the rich of NSW on Queensland. It is equally understandable that Ms. Palaszczuk the Premier of Queensland should wish to repel them.

Queensland needs NSW less than the reverse. Economically our mines, agriculture and essential industries remain operative.

Tourism has brought nothing but disease and foreign cultural and economic hegemony to those parts of Queensland now in deep recession. There has been a hollowing out over forty years of what it means to be a Queenslander.

Who needs NSW?

gg
 
Joined
Nov 15, 2006
Posts
1,181
Reactions
609
WA, Qld and SA are going to regret their border closures if they continue down this path for too long, in my opinion. VIC and NSW will bounce back much faster with freer movement of people between those two states, and soon enough with some overseas countries.

WA, Qld and SA will see the virus come back again, unless they wish to stay closed for for a year or longer...unsustainable practice as the rest of Australian and rest of the World seeks to re-open now, to save jobs and livelihoods.
 
Joined
Jan 29, 2006
Posts
4,771
Reactions
2,019
I support Sir Garpal.
Furthermore, the potential increase in IQ that would flow to Qld would be exceptionally deleterious.
Our prosperous futures - as all investors appreciate - are reliant on continued backwardation.
 

PZ99

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Joined
May 13, 2015
Posts
2,721
Reactions
1,520
Why settle for closing the borders ? Go for the full secede on June 6 with the Q161 banner :)

800px-The_Q150_time_capsule%2C_Brisbane_02.jpg
 

Dona Ferentes

Baron Samedi
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Posts
3,072
Reactions
3,240
I support Sir Garpal.
Furthermore, the potential increase in IQ that would flow to Qld would be exceptionally deleterious.
Our prosperous futures - as all investors appreciate - are reliant on continued backwardation.
wasn't that the old joke, the original win-win: Victorians migrating to Qld help raise the average IQ of both states?

But seriously, now Daylight Saving is over, I don't need to adjust my watch every time I visit, as it doesn't have a decade hand.
 

PZ99

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Joined
May 13, 2015
Posts
2,721
Reactions
1,520
wasn't that the old joke, the original win-win: Victorians migrating to Qld help raise the average IQ of both states?

But seriously, now Daylight Saving is over, I don't need to adjust my watch every time I visit, as it doesn't have a decade hand.
I vaguely remember the tourism ad - "Queensland.. 9am one day, 9am the next" :)
 
Joined
Jan 29, 2006
Posts
4,771
Reactions
2,019
But seriously, now Daylight Saving is over, I don't need to adjust my watch every time I visit, as it doesn't have a decade hand.
It's true that Queenlanders only invested in solar panels to for daylight saving, but we don't wear watches anymore because the left hand never knows what the right hand is doing at the best of times.
 

Bill M

Self Funded Retiree
Joined
Jan 4, 2008
Posts
2,088
Reactions
615
They are desperate for tourists up there.

---
It’s been revealed that the Gold Coast tourism industry is still losing over $300 million a month, while travel restrictions remain in place.

Tourism bosses are already working on the way out of the coronavirus crisis, hoping the industry will bounce back once it’s all over.

Though the longer the Gold Coast is without tourists, the longer our tourism industry suffers.

http://www.mygc.com.au/gold-coast-tourism-industry-still-losing-310m-a-month/

---
 
Joined
Mar 13, 2018
Posts
1,128
Reactions
538
WA, Qld and SA are going to regret their border closures if they continue down this path for too long, in my opinion. VIC and NSW will bounce back much faster with freer movement of people between those two states, and soon enough with some overseas countries.

WA, Qld and SA will see the virus come back again, unless they wish to stay closed for for a year or longer...unsustainable practice as the rest of Australian and rest of the World seeks to re-open now, to save jobs and livelihoods.


New South Wales had the Ruby Princess — I mean, seriously? And they are trying to give us advice on our borders? Do you think I should listen to them? I’m not listening to them.

— Mark McGowan
 
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Posts
5,996
Reactions
5,577
the sheer loss is incredible, in a state with a normal literate Premier, Qld would be crying for the opening of borders, just losing the international travelers is a tragedy.
and now she prevent even Victorians weather refugees to come in.
We all know health is not the issue as our federal expert has been clear there, what for?
 
Joined
May 24, 2009
Posts
1,501
Reactions
1,328
WA, Qld and SA are going to regret their border closures if they continue down this path for too long, in my opinion. VIC and NSW will bounce back much faster with freer movement of people between those two states, and soon enough with some overseas countries.

WA, Qld and SA will see the virus come back again, unless they wish to stay closed for for a year or longer...unsustainable practice as the rest of Australian and rest of the World seeks to re-open now, to save jobs and livelihoods.
Just what is a sustainable practice with Covid-19? Should we look to USA, Brazil?
We are 'opening' quicker than the other states, we are in an enviable position and to keep that, is something most of us value. When the infection rate is acceptable with other entities then border openings will be considered. The second wave is going to be a problem and the worst of that would be another lock down. Not seeing much regret in the closures yet, right now there could be far more regret if we open them. Hopefully patience will bring a greater understanding.
I think in the longer term there is value in keeping covid-19 well managed.
 
Joined
Jan 29, 2006
Posts
4,771
Reactions
2,019
the sheer loss is incredible, in a state with a normal literate Premier, WA would be crying for the opening of borders, just losing the international travelers is a tragedy.
and now he prevents even those Eastern States weather refugees from coming in.
We all know health is not the issue as our federal expert has been clear there, what for?

(with sincere thanks to @qldfrog)
 
Joined
Nov 15, 2006
Posts
1,181
Reactions
609
New South Wales had the Ruby Princess — I mean, seriously? And they are trying to give us advice on our borders? Do you think I should listen to them? I’m not listening to them.

— Mark McGowan
If they want to isolate, it won't affect the rest of the nation much at all. They are far away with a small population. It will cripple their economy though, with a huge impact on tourism, FIFO etc. They are shooting themselves in the foot.
 
Joined
Nov 15, 2006
Posts
1,181
Reactions
609
Just what is a sustainable practice with Covid-19? Should we look to USA, Brazil?
We are 'opening' quicker than the other states, we are in an enviable position and to keep that, is something most of us value. When the infection rate is acceptable with other entities then border openings will be considered. The second wave is going to be a problem and the worst of that would be another lock down. Not seeing much regret in the closures yet, right now there could be far more regret if we open them. Hopefully patience will bring a greater understanding.
I think in the longer term there is value in keeping covid-19 well managed.
I strongly agree it needs careful management. But keeping people in their homes, unemployed, not able to visit friends and family, no tourism etc. is not a sustainable way to manage this virus. It needs to be weighed up with the severe economic and mental health toll which comes with lock-down and border closures. Tourism is one of our biggest industries, and it really needs State borders open to try and start to get back on it's feet.

I doubt any Australian state can isolate itself for an extended period without completely crippling its economy. Furthermore, we ALL have to pay the price of that decision, as that isolated state will end up with more unemployed, more on welfare etc. than other states, which the rest of us have to pay for.

We now have greatly expanded hospital capacity, PPE supplies, contact tracing and new policy around distancing, hygiene etc. for workplaces. I think we have to cop the fact that some people are going to get this virus (and the vast majority will be fine), but we need to go back to work, take a holiday etc. as the alternative is simply unworkable, unless a very effective vaccine comes soon (unlikely!).
 
Joined
Mar 13, 2018
Posts
1,128
Reactions
538
If they want to isolate, it won't affect the rest of the nation much at all. They are far away with a small population. It will cripple their economy though, with a huge impact on tourism, FIFO etc. They are shooting themselves in the foot.
The best thing about Fifo at the moment is social distancing
Planes half full
Crib rooms one per table
Dual cab utes one driver one passenger diagonal in the back
All food now served no self service
Grubs forced to wash their hands
All the interstate scumbags are now here full time which I enjoy reminding them
I’m on 2 on 2off living the dream oh and it’s finally cooled down a bit
 

PZ99

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Joined
May 13, 2015
Posts
2,721
Reactions
1,520
New South Wales had the Ruby Princess — I mean, seriously? And they are trying to give us advice on our borders? Do you think I should listen to them? I’m not listening to them.

— Mark McGowan
Yeppers... it's a geographical war of words between the far left and the far right with everyone else caught in the crossfire.
 
Joined
Jan 29, 2006
Posts
4,771
Reactions
2,019
Yeppers... it's a geographical war of words between the far left and the far right with everyone else caught in the crossfire.
I have made a fortune in recent months smuggling desperate Cornstalks and Mexicans across the border.
If you have loved ones in need of the Queen's blessing please contact my agent @peterdutton.5 who pays our Border Force well to turn a blind eye.
 
Joined
May 24, 2009
Posts
1,501
Reactions
1,328
Tourism is one of our biggest industries, and it really needs State borders open to try and start to get back on it's feet.
In the meantime we will need the locals to step up and have more holidays within their own states. Which frankly is long overdue. This is probably the opportunity to rebalance priority, if it really matters of where to spend money as a tourist.
I think Australia will become a holiday destination of choice. Who's crowded beach or bar would you feel safest to be in, one in an Australia or Brazil (leave the sharks out of this :))
We are almost there, bars and beaches are very soon open, and will be appreciated much more.
 
Joined
Nov 15, 2006
Posts
1,181
Reactions
609
In the meantime we will need the locals to step up and have more holidays within their own states. Which frankly is long overdue. This is probably the opportunity to rebalance priority, if it really matters of where to spend money as a tourist.
I think Australia will become a holiday destination of choice. Who's crowded beach or bar would you feel safest to be in, one in an Australia or Brazil (leave the sharks out of this :))
We are almost there, bars and beaches are very soon open, and will be appreciated much more.
Agree. There's a number of silver linings in this crisis.
 

Similar threads

Top