Australian (ASX) Stock Market Forum

Best Online Broker?!

Bill M

Self Funded Retiree
Joined
4 January 2008
Posts
2,132
Reactions
740
What are your thoughts on etrade?

Same problem as NabTrade, when I had my account they wouldn't give me credit until T3. I had to have the money in my account to buy even though I had a portfolio with them. My beef is that I don't like tying up 1,000's of $$$ in my trading account earning next to no interest whilst waiting for that right trade. I prefer them to give me credit until T3 and then I BPay my funds into my account when needed. Some brokers allow you to do that and others don't.

My Etrade account was some years ago so it may have changed by now.
 
Joined
15 April 2013
Posts
15
Reactions
1
Does comsec? I bank through ANZ and that's why I went with etrade.

Comsec wanted to charge me more because I didn't have a bank account with them...
 

Bill M

Self Funded Retiree
Joined
4 January 2008
Posts
2,132
Reactions
740
Does comsec? I bank through ANZ and that's why I went with etrade.

Comsec wanted to charge me more because I didn't have a bank account with them...

That's right they will charge your more if you do not apply for the CDIA account. I have that CDIA account linked to my brokerage account, all trades are settled through there. However, I do not keep any money in that linked account. As I hold stocks with them they give me credit until T3. On T2 I transfer my purchase funds into that CDIA account. You do not need to have the funds there first.

I am currently earning 4.75% in a cash account at call. I will never leaver leave cash in my brokerage account earning next to nothing. I don't trade that often so it pays for me to get credit until T3 and BPay the funds in, cheers.
 
Joined
27 December 2010
Posts
1,729
Reactions
48
Use it all the time. Currently 4.288% for balances up to -$100K. Unlike CommSec, their brokerage is no different for purchases on margin as opposed to cash.

Is there anything specifically you want to know about margin for Aus equities?

Ok cool. I was interested in finding out the LVR's for equities?
 

Julia

In Memoriam
Joined
10 May 2005
Posts
16,986
Reactions
1,968
Same problem as NabTrade, when I had my account they wouldn't give me credit until T3. I had to have the money in my account to buy even though I had a portfolio with them. My beef is that I don't like tying up 1,000's of $$$ in my trading account earning next to no interest whilst waiting for that right trade. I prefer them to give me credit until T3 and then I BPay my funds into my account when needed. Some brokers allow you to do that and others don't.

My Etrade account was some years ago so it may have changed by now.
I'm with Etrade and it's still the same. I don't find it a problem at all, as I can do an on the spot transfer of the funds from my ANZ at call a/c (presently 4.65%) into the Etrade cash a/c where it's immediately available.

Agree entirely that you wouldn't want any reasonable amount sitting in the miserably rewarded broker cash a/c.
 

ROE

Joined
5 January 2007
Posts
2,966
Reactions
20
That's right they will charge your more if you do not apply for the CDIA account. I have that CDIA account linked to my brokerage account, all trades are settled through there. However, I do not keep any money in that linked account. As I hold stocks with them they give me credit until T3. On T2 I transfer my purchase funds into that CDIA account. You do not need to have the funds there first.

I am currently earning 4.75% in a cash account at call. I will never leaver leave cash in my brokerage account earning next to nothing. I don't trade that often so it pays for me to get credit until T3 and BPay the funds in, cheers.

You can usually transfer 8am on t+3 day, you get an extra day on high interest account...
They dont settle until cob t+3 but they normally run a check early on in the morning and said your trade failed to settle because the cash is not there but they do it again at the end of the day so I ignore the sms so make sure the cash is in early on t+3 day....

I also like their new settlement calculation you can do trade within the t+3 period and they settle the differences
I been trading a fair bit lately i do about 3-4 trade during those t+3 and i dont have to put any money in
If they all profitable trade ...GOLD :)

500-1000 cones in every few day without any cash up front and that cash sit there in high interest account..double bonus
 
Joined
18 September 2008
Posts
4,041
Reactions
1,184
Ok cool. I was interested in finding out the LVR's for equities?

Sorry, I can't help you there. They explain it on their web site, but as I normally keep my LVR under 20% and as their reports show that I am well below their limits, I haven't paid any attention to the detailed calculation.
 
Joined
8 April 2014
Posts
50
Reactions
0
The commsec interface is the worst for sure.

1) The plus500 is very simple and clear,
example, The main menu is (trade, position, order, history),


in commsec interface, where to check the trading history?? it is not as clear as plus500.

in commsec interface, the records sometimes do not show up. you need to click two times sometimes.


2) The CBA was developed by fools.

example, when u use a CBA ATM, after u withdraw some cash, the screen display a question " do you want to vote this transaction as your favour transaction?"

-it is idiotic.
 
Joined
30 October 2016
Posts
2
Reactions
0
Hi Everyone,

I am wanting to sign up with an online broker in the future and was wandering now that a lot of these mediums have had time to fix up their problems which broker with the following would be best for a beginner like myself both in shares and using an online broker.

- Provides reports
- local and international trades
- FOREX

I have a NAB account but happy to move for the right online broker as I have heard nothing but bad reports regarding NABtrade.

Regards

Dan
 
Joined
6 January 2010
Posts
2
Reactions
0
Looking for the cheapest brokerage so that I can trade on the ASX....

So far I am looking at CMC Markets and IG Markets - just talking shares and not CFD's. Any cheaper going without having to jump through a million hoops like IB?

Cheers.
 
Joined
1 May 2007
Posts
2,904
Reactions
51
Looking for the cheapest brokerage so that I can trade on the ASX....

So far I am looking at CMC Markets and IG Markets - just talking shares and not CFD's. Any cheaper going without having to jump through a million hoops like IB?

Cheers.

OpenMarkets - 7bps inc gst
 

PZ99

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Joined
13 May 2015
Posts
3,241
Reactions
2,318
Head's up for ANZ / E Trade users. Without informing its users they've increased their brokerage for the first trade of each month as of today...

16473438_1747845308878017_7767807472340058943_n.jpg


Bit grubby if you ask me :speechless:
 

pixel

DIY Trader
Joined
3 February 2010
Posts
5,359
Reactions
339
OpenMarkets - 7bps inc gst
... and they're happy to link your trading account to a Macquarie CMA. If you're with another bank, give them a call to check.
Another nice feature: If you wish to take several small bites at a stock - e.g. ease into TLS at $5, hoping it'll go up, add some more at $5.005 (yes, you can also request a centre crossing), etc., up to 12 (could be more meanwhile) trades (same day, same stock, same direction) will raise only one Contract Note and one Brokerage.
And "frequent traders" pay nothing for the software, Pulse.
 
Joined
28 March 2006
Posts
3,505
Reactions
1,200
Just had a look at OpenMarkets site. I like the idea of being able to ease into trades, sometimes needed on larger priced stocks and something I still miss from the TraderDealer days prior to the Opes Prime failure.

One of the directors on there, Rick Klink, I have heard that name somewhere before, anyone familiar ?
Got a feeling he may have even been from TraderDealer.
 

pixel

DIY Trader
Joined
3 February 2010
Posts
5,359
Reactions
339
One of the directors on there, Rick Klink, I have heard that name somewhere before, anyone familiar ?
I've met Paritech's owners Rick and Paul ten years ago, well before the Opes and Tricom debacles. I don't know how long their company had existed at that time, but their flagship software package, Pulse, was already quite mature. AND FAST!!!

It was their competitor, MDS Financial, who took over TraderDealer - from memory, sometime in 2008. Not to be confused with Trade-Tech, a training company that sold the Market Analyser and, in its early years, had links with the Sharemarket College and Tricom.
 
Joined
28 March 2006
Posts
3,505
Reactions
1,200
Aah, now I know where from.
My SMSF was originally set up via Paritech years ago, I reckon I may have actually met him on one of my two visits to the Paritech office in Melbourne.
Knew the name rang a bell, thanks pixel.
 
Top